Lisa and Jim's Northern Nevada Real Estate Blog

Do Bloggers have to give up their sources?

This is a very interesting question!  I will be most interested to hear the outcome and hope you keep us posted!  In the mean time ... great job!  Thanks for sharing this intriguing information!

Interesting perspective ... enjoy this blog fromWayne and Jean Marie Zuhl from Clark, NJ

Are bloggers given the same protective rights as journalists?

Of course, the shield laws that protect journalists' sources are critical to providing news. Without this protection, journalists would find it nearly impossible to find credible and publishable information. But do these laws apply to bloggers? If a blogger has an unnamed source for a blog post, is that blogger legally required to give up the name of the source if law enforcement requests?

This is the question being decided in a Union County Courthouse. Tina Renna is a write for   The CountyWatchers.com blog and often writes posts criticizing Union County officials. In December, she wrote a blog post saying that she knew the names of 16 County employees who illegally (not to mention unethically) used county-owned generators after Hurricane Sandy.

Theodore Romankow of the Union County Prosecutor's Office served her with a subpoena requesting the names of these 16 County employees to investigate the claims but Renna refused. She claims that the shield law protects her as a journalist and that she has no obligation to reveal her sources.

Romankow says she's impeding an ongoing investigation into improper use of generators and has insisted he doesn't want Renna's sources but only the 16 names she claims she has. Renna says that revealing the names will possibly reveal her source and has refused, citing shield laws to protect her.

The Prosecutors Office says that blogs aren't "news media" and therefore not protected by shield laws. Since Renna's posts aren't objective, they aren't considered journalism and therefore not protected.

Should Renna be forced to give up her names, therefore losing not only this source but all future sources who will no longer trust her? Since Renna has been a political watchdog of sorts, collecting information on Union County government and calling them to task publicly, should she have the same rights as a reporter to protect those sources? Does forcing her to give up the names become a gag order of sorts - crippling her ability to publish information on the government? Should government watchdogs be protected?

Very intense discussions in Union County courthouses this week. I, for one, will be watching....

File:Handcuffs01 2003-06-02.jpg

 

 




~ Wayne & Jean 


Union County, NJ - a great place to live and work!


If you're looking to buy or sell a property in Union County, call us at 908-917-4189 or email TeamZuhl@gmail.com.

Check us out on Facebook at Real Estate Today and Things to Do in Union County! Follow us on Pinterest and Twitter.


All opinions, information and data provided is deemed reliable but is subject to errors and omissions. Not intended to solicit other Brokers' clients. We cooperate with them fully. 

Comment balloon 2 commentsLisa Wetzel • February 02 2013 06:18AM
Do Bloggers have to give up their sources?
share
This is a very interesting question! I will be most interested to hear the outcome and hope you keep us posted! In the mean time.. great job! Thanks for sharing this intriguing information! Interesting perspective.. enjoy this blog… more
Sold and Closed! 2685 Skyline Dr. Minden, Nevada 89423
share
more
Northern Nevada Real Estate.. Be Smart With Your Cash
share
Northern Nevada Real Estate Be Smart With Your Cash Lisa Wetzel and Jim Valentine &… more
Pending Under Offer! 726 Lassen Way Gardnerville, Nevada 89460
share
more
Pending Under Offer! 454 Sheep Camp Drive Dayton, Nevada 89403
share
more
Carson River Frontage in Genoa, NV 524 Genoa Ln Genoa NV 12. 7 Acres
share
more
Pending Under Offer! 2685 Skyline Dr. Minden, Nevada 89423
share
$429, 900. 00 - Pending Under… more
Myth or Fact? A better deal on New Construction without an agent.
share
Great Post.. Soooo True! People think they are smarter than the average agent! The "Best" service they can give them selves is to enlist the representation of a good agent and stick with it! This is an outstanding Blog! Thank You!.. more
Northern Nevada Real Estate Back Up Offer Northern Nevada Real Estate
share
Lisa and Jim's Northern Nevada Real Estate The Back Up Offer… more
Northern Nevada Real Estate.. What Comes With The House?
share
Northern Nevada Real Estate What Comes With The House? Lisa Wetzel and Jim Valentine RE/MAX Realty Affiliates … more
Northern Nevada Real Estate Luxury Home Short Sales
share
Northern Nevada Real Estate Luxury Home Short Sales Lisa Wetzel and Jim Valentine RE/MAX Realty… more
1355 Sandstone Wellington, Nevada 89444 - $105, 000
share
$105, 000. 00 - 1355 Sandstone Wellington, Nevada 89444 - $105, 000.. Amazing Housing Value! Wonderful… more
454 Sheep Camp Drive Dayton, Nevada 89403. Impressive 4 Bedroom Home
share
$151, 500. 00 - 454 Sheep Camp… more
726 Lassen Way Gardnerville, Nevada 89460.. A Real Doll House
share
$135, 000. 00 - 726 Lassen Way… more
1343 Elges Avenue Gardnerville, Nevada 89410 Heart of Gardnerville!
share
$296, 500. 00 - 1343… more
Old Sawmill Industrial Park. Carson Valley Industrial Lots For Sale
share
$125, 000. 00 - Old Sawmill… more
Pending.. 1473 Foothill Rd - Carson Valley Ranch Land Opportunity
share
$875, 000. 00 - Pending Under… more
Northern Nevada Real Estate.. Credit Nightmares Of The Innocent
share
Northern Nevada Real Estate Credit Nightmares Of The Innocent Lisa Wetzel and Jim Valentine RE/MAX Ralty Affiliates … more
Northern Nevada Real Estate Critical Short Sale Timing
share
Northern Nevada Real Estate Critical Short Sale Timing Lisa Wetzel and Jim Valentine RE/MAX Realty Affiliates … more
Successfully Closed Short Sale! 1411 Amanda Ct Gardnerville, NV 89460
share
$174, 900. 00 - Another… more